Skip to content
Personalised assessment
Onagre et bourrache : quelle différence et laquelle choisir ?

Evening primrose and borage: what’s the difference and which should you choose?

Contents

Evening primrose or borage, or both together? These two plant oils are often found side by side in the food supplements aisle, sometimes combined in the same capsule. This article compares their fatty acid composition, what studies show about skin and women’s health, why they may be combined, how to use them and the precautions to be aware of. To learn more about evening primrose, visit our dedicated page on evening primrose oil.

Did you know?

Borage leaves and flowers naturally contain pyrrolizidine alkaloids, substances that are toxic to the liver: this is why borage herbal teas are not recommended. The oil extracted from the seeds contains virtually none (10). For added safety, choose a tested oil labelled ‘guaranteed free from pyrrolizidine alkaloids’.

In summary

  1. Evening primrose and borage provide the same fatty acid, gamma-linolenic acid (GLA), an omega-6 fatty acid that the body converts into messengers with anti-inflammatory properties. Borage contains two to three times as much as evening primrose.
  2. Both oils have shown benefits for the skin : evening primrose improved skin hydration, elasticity and firmness, while borage reduced water loss from the skin and the feeling of dryness. Their effect on eczema, however, has not been confirmed.
  3. Evening primrose is the most studied oil for the menstrual cycle and menopause, making it the better-studied choice for supporting women’s comfort.
  4. Combining them increases GLA intake without taking more capsules, as borage is more concentrated. However, studies have tested each oil separately.
  5. These oils are generally well tolerated, but require medical advice if you are taking anticoagulant medication. For borage, choose an oil guaranteed to be free from alkaloids, and avoid both oils during pregnancy and breastfeeding.
Jolly Mama Evening Primrose Mama, evening primrose oil food supplement, amber glass bottle and capsules
Every day

Evening Primrose Mama

Evening primrose oil capsule

£19.04

£23.80

To support your cycle

For skin and hair

Organically grown seeds

100% vegan, carrageenan-free

Discover

Evening primrose oil and borage oil: origin, extraction and composition

Evening primrose is a plant native to North America, with yellow flowers that open at dusk. Borage is a Mediterranean plant with star-shaped blue flowers. In both cases, the oil is extracted from the seeds, most often by cold pressing.

In France, both oils are mainly sold as food supplements in softgels or capsules, often made from organic seeds. They are also available as pure plant oils for use on the skin.

These two oils share a rare advantage: they provide gamma-linolenic acid, or GLA, a fatty acid in the omega-6 family. The body converts it into DGLA, which it uses to produce series 1 prostaglandins, chemical messengers that contribute to the regulation of inflammation (3). The main difference is how much they contain: evening primrose oil contains 8 to 10 % GLA (1), while borage oil contains approximately 20 to 25 % (2). At the same dose, borage oil therefore provides two to three times as much GLA.

Evening primrose oilBorage oil
Plant originNorth AmericaMediterranean region
Part usedSeedsSeeds
Gamma-linolenic acid (GLA)8 to 10 % (1)Approximately 20 to 25 % (2)
Most studied areasSkin and the menstrual cycle (4) (7)Skin and joints (5) (8)
Main precautionNot recommended during pregnancy or breastfeeding.Choose a tested oil, free from the toxic alkaloids present in the plant. Not recommended during pregnancy or breastfeeding.
Take care, mama

Even a carefully chosen oil can support your wellbeing, but it cannot replace a consultation. If discomfort persists or worries you, speak to your doctor, midwife or pharmacist: they can help you choose what is right for you.

Evening primrose and borage: what the studies show

For the skin

The skin cannot convert linoleic acid into GLA itself: to obtain it, GLA must be supplied directly through the diet or a supplement (5). This is what makes these two oils, widely used in beauty supplements, of interest for supple, well-hydrated skin.

Evening primrose oil was tested in a placebo-controlled trial involving 40 healthy adults. After 12 weeks of oral intake, skin hydration had increased by 12.9 %, transepidermal water loss had decreased by 7.7 %, and elasticity (suppleness), firmness and roughness had all improved compared with the placebo group (4).

Borage oil was studied in 29 healthy adults over two months. Water loss from the skin decreased by 10.8 %, the proportion of people reporting dry skin fell from 42 to 14 %, and the proportion reporting itching fell from 34 % to none (5).

Eczema, the longest-standing use of these oils, has not been supported by the evidence: a review of 27 trials bringing together studies on this subject found no greater improvement than with a placebo (6).

Hair and nails are often mentioned among the beauty benefits of these oils. However, these uses have not yet been supported by robust studies, and the results remain to be confirmed.

For the menstrual cycle and menopause

Evening primrose oil is the most studied oil for premenstrual syndrome, breast tenderness and menopause (7) (9) (11). Explore our collections for premenstrual syndrome and menopause.

For the joints

A Cochrane review concludes that oils rich in GLA (evening primrose, borage or blackcurrant seed oil) probably reduce pain in rheumatoid arthritis (8).

Discover our products
The Jolly tip

Before choosing an oil, identify what is really bothering you. Skin that feels tight, breast tenderness before your period and hot flushes are different concerns. Make a note of your symptoms over one or two cycles: this will help you decide which oil to try and assess its effects honestly after three months.

Plant oil, capsules, organic supplements: which form should you choose?

Pure plant oil is mainly applied to the skin, on its own or mixed with a cream.

Softgels or capsules are the form used in studies of oral intake. They make it possible to know exactly how much oil and GLA is taken each day. To choose a quality product, check the ingredients list: some formulas include vitamin E, which protects the oil from oxidation. Supplements made from organically grown seeds also guarantee that the seeds were grown without synthetic pesticides. The price of an evening primrose or borage food supplement depends mainly on its GLA content, the quality of the oil and its organic certification. The useful information on the label is the amount of GLA per daily dose, whether it contains vitamin E and, for borage, the statement “guaranteed free from pyrrolizidine alkaloids”. To compare prices, look at the amount of GLA rather than the number of capsules. For evening primrose, also check that it contains no carrageenan and check what the capsule is made from: many are of animal origin. 

When it comes to quality, the extraction method matters: the oil can be obtained by cold pressing or using solvents, and these processes affect its composition (1). “Virgin, cold-pressed oil” is a useful indication to look for on the label.

Evening primrose and borage: how to use them and dosage

For evening primrose, studies on the menstrual cycle used 1.5 g of oil per day (7), while the skin trial used a little more (4). For borage, the skin study provided 360 to 720 mg of GLA per day (5). Take your capsules with a meal and follow the dose recommended in the leaflet for your chosen food supplement.

These oils need to be taken regularly: in the studies, effects and results were observed after two to three months of use (4) (5) (7).

Evening primrose or borage: why combine them, and which should you choose?

The two oils are often combined because they provide the same fatty acid. Borage is more concentrated, allowing you to increase your GLA intake without taking more capsules, and many supplements contain both oils. Evening primrose is the oil most studied in relation to the menstrual cycle. However, trials have tested each oil separately: whether combining them has a greater effect has not yet been assessed.

Your choice therefore depends on what you are looking for:

  • For women who want to support their menstrual cycle, evening primrose has the most supporting data.
  • For a more concentrated source of GLA, borage lets you take fewer capsules, provided you choose an oil guaranteed free from alkaloids.
  • To combine the two, a combined capsule is an option, provided you check the total amount of GLA per day.

Evening primrose and borage: side effects and contraindications

Taken orally, oils rich in GLA are generally well tolerated. In the joint trials, adverse effects were not significantly more common than with placebo (8). Some people experience mild digestive discomfort or headaches (8).

In some situations, you should seek advice from a healthcare professional before starting. If you have a blood-clotting problem or are taking anticoagulants, ask your doctor for advice: the authors of the Cochrane review on eczema urge caution because of the risk of bleeding (6).

During pregnancy and breastfeeding, there is insufficient safety data on these oils for both mother and baby: it is best to avoid them (2) (12). This is why the Jolly Mama evening primrose oil capsule is not recommended during these periods.

Why this product?

Evening Primrose Mama is a capsule containing 100% evening primrose oil: it contains no borage oil. Its daily dose of 3 capsules provides 1,500 mg of oil, the dose used in studies on the cycle, including 135 mg of gamma-linolenic acid. The oil is cold-pressed from organically grown seeds and supplied in vegan capsules. Evening primrose provides polyunsaturated fatty acids that help maintain well-being during the menstrual cycle. Find it alongside our other products for women in their forties in the menopause collection.

Jolly Mama Evening Primrose Mama, evening primrose oil food supplement, amber glass bottle and capsules
Every day

Evening Primrose Mama

Evening primrose oil capsule

£19.04

£23.80

To support your cycle

For skin and hair

Organically grown seeds

100% vegan, carrageenan-free

Discover

Other recommended products

The actives associated with this article

Jolly Mama Evening Primrose Mama, evening primrose oil food supplement, amber glass bottle and capsules Femme tenant une gélule de complément alimentaire avec un verre d'eau
Promo -20%
New

Evening Primrose Mama

Evening primrose oil capsule

To care for your menstrual cycle, skin and hair

Every day

Quality vegan oil standardised to 9% GLA

For your cycle, skin and hair

from

£16.19

£23.80

Recommended products

Our best offer of the year

20% off everything on the site

Jolly Mama Evening Primrose Mama, evening primrose oil food supplement, amber glass bottle and capsules
New
Promo -20%

Evening Primrose Mama

Evening primrose oil capsule

Every day

from

£16.19

£23.80

Your questions, our answers.

Answer to the question.

Answer to the question.

Answer to the question.

Answer to the question.

Answer to the question.

Answer to the question.

added to cart