During breastfeeding, as we have also seen above, even with an optimised diet and appropriate caloric supplementation, vitamin D intake did not meet recommended needs. So what can be done if we are not reaching the recommended levels? We can turn to supplementation. But in that case, which type of vitamin D should we take? Which supplement should we go for?
Vitamin D2 vs vitamin D3: which should you choose?
There are two forms of vitamin D: D3, or cholecalciferol, and D2, or ergocalciferol.
Vitamin D2 (or ergocalciferol) is produced by plants and fungi.
Vitamin D3 (or cholecalciferol) is found in many foods, particularly those of animal origin and in certain lichens, and is produced by the skin under the action of ultraviolet rays.
Vitamin D3 is formed when 7-dehydrocholesterol present in the skin is exposed to UVB rays from the sun, then converted into provitamin D3. In a heat-dependent process, provitamin D3 is immediately transformed into vitamin D. This form increases calcium absorption in the digestive tract, enhances its reabsorption in the kidneys, and supports bone mineralisation.
Vitamin D2, for its part, is produced exogenously through irradiation of ergosterol, and enters the body's circulation via food [10].
Several studies have reported that the bioefficacy of vitamin D3 is significantly greater than that of D2, and have indicated that supplementation should therefore be based on vitamin D3 [11].
The majority of vitamin D supplements are therefore made from vitamin D3, which can be extracted from lanolin (a fat derived from sheep's wool) or from boreal lichen, a plant-based source.
Vitamin D supplementation for the breastfeeding mother?
A study on pregnant women found a vitamin D deficiency in more than 75% of participants! [12]. Pregnant women and breastfeeding mothers are recommended to consume sufficient vitamin D or to take a supplement if necessary. Women who are unsure of their vitamin D status should carry out a simple blood test before choosing to take a supplement.
Although supplementing infants may be recommended, as we will see below, studies have shown that high-dose supplementation in the mother could be sufficient to meet both her needs and those of her baby. Indeed, one study found that at a dose of 6,400 IU/day, the breastfeeding mother had enough vitamin D for herself and her baby, with no adverse effects related to overdose — which could make it feasible to supplement only the mother [13]. Maintaining the mother's optimal vitamin D status is the key determinant in preventing deficiency in the child.
Do be mindful of overdosing, however. There are currently gaps in the assessment of the toxicity risk associated with excessive vitamin D supplementation. It is therefore advisable not to exceed 4,000 IU/day, as excess has been associated with hypercalcaemia. That said, nothing stops us from supplementing for our own benefit first!
It is always advisable to consult a healthcare professional to identify your own needs and determine any additional quantities required.
Vitamin D supplementation for the breastfed infant
Your child's vitamin D needs are 400 IU/day (according to the latest recommendations currently being updated), and the French Society of Paediatrics recommends supplementing all infants with vitamin D to ensure adequate status [14].
According to La Leche League, the risk of vitamin deficiency is higher in children with darker skin, those with limited direct sun exposure, those exclusively breastfed for an extended period by a mother with low calcium and vitamin D intake during pregnancy [15].
More specifically, infants depend on the vitamin D content of hindmilk (defined as the last milk of a feed), as studies show that this end-of-feed milk is richer in vitamin D than foremilk (the first milk of a feed) [16].
Did you know? Breast milk is more likely to contain higher levels of vitamin D in summer than in winter!
Moreover, breast milk is a poor source of vitamin D. Exclusively breastfed infants receive less than 20% of the daily dose recommended by the Institute of Medicine for infants during the first year of life [17].
This supports the recommendation that vitamin D supplementation should be given to all children, at least until the age of 18 months.